|
|
How should public health concerns be considered in the process of creating new trademarks for the pharmaceutical industry in Europe?The European Medicines Evaluation Agency (EMEA) and its policy on accepting tradenames
The granting of an authorization to market medicinal products under the centralized procedure requires that the applicant puts forward a single pan-European tradename. Although it is not mandatory under EU legislation for the name of a medicinal product to be a registered trademark companies submitting marketing authorization applications under Community systems prefer the use of trademarks over International Non-Proprietary Names (INNs).
In evaluating the safety of medicinal products in the authorization procedure the EMEA is obliged to consider whether the proposed trademark of a medicinal product could create a risk to public safety. The possibility of someone mistakenly taking one drug in place of another because the drug names are similar can have very serious consequences. Perhaps nowhere is vigilance more important than when selecting medicinal products. Since many medication errors are caused by look-alike and sound-alike medication names it is evident that even where a registered trademark exists public health considerations must determine whether that trademark may be used for a medicinal product.
In communication CPMP/328/98, Revision 3 dated January 2002 the EMEA Committee for Proprietary Medicinal Products has now published the difficulties which have typically been encountered with product tradenames arising from such public safety concerns. The features of proposed tradenames which give rise to confusion are summarized below:
-
The tradename of a medicinal product should not be liable to cause confusion in print, handwriting or speech with the tradename of an existing medicinal product;
-
The tradename of a medicinal product should not be liable to cause confusion in print, handwriting or speech with an established Non-Proprietary Name (INN) relating to a different active ingredient.
Objections to tradenames based on risk of confusion as described above is the most recurrent basis for objection. As a rule of thumb, if there is a minimum of 3 distinguishing letters, it is unlikely that it will be considered that there is a risk of confusion in writing;
-
The tradename of a medicinal product should not convey misleading therapeutic or pharmaceutical connotations, e.g. the German trademark CARDIODORON® should only be used for medicinal products for the treatment of cardiovascular diseases;
-
The tradename of a medicinal product should not be misleading with respect to the composition of the product;
-
The tradename of a product should avoid qualification by letters;
-
Qualification of a name by a single detached letter and by numbers is unacceptable;
-
The tradename should comply with World Health Organization (WHO) Guidance, e.g. it should not incorporate a "generic stem" which has been adopted and published by the WHO. However, if used, the product should conform to the pharmacological, therapeutic or chemical connotation implicit in the stem.
The WHO plays an essential role in assigning chemical drug substance names. The WHO is the world body co-ordinating the International Non-Proprietary Name (INN) of each drug substance. Since 1972 more than 6,000 names have been assigned to chemical substances with possible medical uses. These names can be easily recognized by those involved in the drug development and delivery process such as chemists, toxicologists, manufacturers, physicians and pharmacists. In practice the nomenclature systems, parallel use of trademarks and generic names, are not dissociated by according exclusivity of the INN common stems but the WHO Secretariat attempts to create awareness that the practice to apply for trademarks clearly derived from, although not identical with, INNs endangers the principle that INNs are public property. It can frustrate the selection of further INNs for related substances.
For further information on INNs please refer to the following WHO publications:
- The Use of common stems in the selection of International nonproprietary names (INNs) for pharmaceutical substances: August 1999
World Health Organization Quality Assurance and Safety: Medicines, Essential Drugs and other Medicines
Geneva World Health Organization 1999
Document No.: WHO/EDM/QSM/99.6
Electronic access:
http://whqlibdoc.who.int/hq/1999/WHO_EDM_QSM_99.6.pdf 152 Seiten, 5402 K
- Guidelines on the use of International nonproprietary names (INNs) for pharmaceutical substances
World Health Organization Programme on International Nonproprietary Names
Geneva World Health Organization 1997
Document No.: WHO/PHARM S/NOM 1570
Electronic access:
http://whqlibdoc.who.int/hq/1997/WHO_PHARM_S_NOM_1570.pdf 40 Seiten, 1105 K
|
-
|